Skip to main content

I Can Only Imagine 2 (2026)


I Can Only Imagine 2 continues the story established in the original film, but it relies too heavily on manufactured drama to justify its existence. Rather than allowing conflict to arise naturally, the screenplay feels like it's throwing darts at a wall, pulling together different events simply to create another emotional character arc. Director Andrew Erwin once again proves he can get the most out of his cast despite the weaker material, doing his best to elevate a script that often undermines the growth established in the first film. Unfortunately, much of the character development that made the original so effective feels lost here, making this sequel a noticeable step down.

John Michael Finley returns as Bart, but his portrayal leans far more into melodrama this time around. While it's understandable that the screenplay wants to give its protagonist another emotional journey, it comes at the expense of believable character progression. After everything his character experienced in the first film, it's difficult to accept that he would still behave with the emotional immaturity presented here. The performance itself is committed, but the writing asks Finley to revisit lessons that should have already been learned.

Milo Ventimiglia, known for Heroes and Rocky Balboa, is an excellent addition to the cast. As always, he delivers a dependable performance that adds credibility whenever he's on screen. Sammy Dell is also a pleasant surprise, making the most of the opportunity and turning in one of the film's stronger performances. Together, the supporting cast often outshines the material they're given, helping to keep the film engaging even when the screenplay struggles.

Overall, I Can Only Imagine 2 never reaches the emotional heights of its predecessor. Andrew Erwin directs with confidence and gets solid performances from his cast, particularly Milo Ventimiglia and Sammy Dell, but the screenplay sacrifices believable character progression in favor of forced drama. While fans of the original may still find moments to appreciate, this sequel ultimately feels like a weaker retread rather than a meaningful continuation. Result: C-

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Whalefall (2026)

Whalefall is a suspense drama written and directed by Brian Duffield , known for directing Spontaneous and No One Will Save You . The film brings Austin Abrams and Josh Brolin together again after Weapons , this time in a story that combines a strained father-son relationship with a claustrophobic survival thriller. The movie does a good job balancing flashbacks with the increasingly terrifying situation in the present. There are some genuinely tense moments that make you feel trapped alongside the main character, and the flashbacks give the story some much-needed breathing room. Austin Abrams , who has had a great run with Weapons last year and Resident Evil this year, is quickly becoming one of Hollywood's go to leading men. He does a great job carrying the film, balancing the physical demands of the survival story with the emotional baggage his character brings into it. He has a natural screen presence that makes him easy to root for, and this is another strong performance...
Post a Comment
Read more

Iron Lung (2026)

Iron Lung (2026) is a contained sci fi horror film set almost entirely in one confined space, built around tension, isolation, and curiosity more than outright scares. The movie leans into claustrophobia and atmosphere over shock value. It feels closer to Pandorum than a traditional horror film. Knowing it is not a big budget production makes it easier to forgive some of its rough edges. Markiplier is  known primarily as a major YouTube creator and voice actor in projects like First  Nights at Freddy’s . He is the writer, director and star of the film. Carrying a one room film is not easy, especially without classical acting training, but he does a pretty good job. His performance is committed and focused, and he understands how to hold attention on himself without constant visual change. As a director and writer, he shows promise, especially with pacing and mood. Troy Baker , well known for voice roles in The Last of Us and BioShock Infinite , appears in the film, though...
Post a Comment
Read more

The Lazarus Effect (2015)

The Lazarus Effect is a film I never got around to watching when it was released in 2015 so seeing it eleven years later certainly makes for an interesting experience. Directed by David Gelb , best known for the documentary Jiro Dreams of Sushi , the film tries to blend scientific experimentation with supernatural horror. Unfortunately, it spends far too much time explaining the science behind its premise and not nearly enough time making any of it frightening. There is an interesting concept buried underneath all the exposition, but the movie seems more concerned with explaining how everything works than actually scaring its audience. Olivia Wilde , known for Tron: Legacy and House , is probably the film's biggest asset, though not necessarily because of her acting. She has a screen presence that keeps the movie interesting whenever she is around, and the direction wisely seems to understand that she is more effective on screen than some of her costars. Unfortunately, the film d...
Post a Comment
Read more