Skip to main content

I Know What You Did Last Summer (2025)


I Know What You Did Last Summer (2025) is a modern reboot that struggles under the weight of its own messaging.

Written and directed by Jennifer Kaytin Robinson, known for Do Revenge and co-writing Thor: Love and Thunder, the script leans heavily into a feminist slant that often feels forced and out of sync with the slasher tone. Instead of enhancing the story, it undercuts tension with cringeworthy dialogue and awkward character beats.

Madelyn Cline, seen in Outer Banks and Glass Onion, is easily the film’s highlight. She delivers the most natural performance, blending beauty with presence, and does her best to anchor a shaky narrative. Unfortunately, the material rarely rises to meet her.

Tyriq Withers, who appears in The Game and has the upcoming film Him. I'm quite excited to see how he does in that. He's likable and shows promise. His role is disappointingly small, sidelined by Robinson’s writing choices. He deserved more screen time and depth, as his charisma stands out even in brief moments.

Jonah Hauer-King, known for The Little Mermaid and World on Fire, plays the love interest but is literally referred to as a “beta” in the script, and the portrayal matches. It’s an odd creative decision that makes it difficult to root for his character in a genre where likability and chemistry are key.

Nepobaby Chase Sui Wonders, from Bodies Bodies Bodies and The Studio, fails to lead the cast as the supposed new final girl. Despite effort, she lacks the weight and emotional resonance needed, especially when compared to Jennifer Love Hewitt’s iconic original. The attempt to recapture the magic just doesn’t land. The ending ruins the film.

Result: D+

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Psycho Killer (2026)

Psycho Killer (2026) is a religious-tinged detective thriller that leans far more into procedural tension than outright horror. Directed by Gavin Polone , who is better known as a producer than a filmmaker, the movie benefits heavily from its screenplay by Andrew Kevin Walker , the writer behind Se7en . His fingerprints are all over this. The writing is sharp, layered with foreshadowing that only fully clicks at the end, and structured in a way that constantly feels like it is building toward something inevitable. The gorgeous  Georgina Campbell plays the detective tracking down the titular killer, and she carries the film with confidence. You'll remember her from Barbarian and recently Cold Storage.  The script gives her plenty of emotional range to explore, from controlled professionalism to visible cracks under pressure. She handles the lore-heavy exposition well and grounds what could have been overwhelming backstory. It is another strong showing for her and proof she c...
Post a Comment
Read more

Cold Storage (2026)

Cold Storage (2026) is a sci fi horror thriller that surprised me in a good way. The writing is solid enough that it actually calmed some of my worries about Disclosure Day coming later this year since the same writer is involved. The story holds together and stays engaging, even when the visuals do not. The CG is laughably bad at times, but the acting/chemistry keeps the movie watchable. Jonny Campbell directs, with the screenplay by David Koepp , known for Jurassic Park and Spider-Man . His writing here is tighter than expected, which is why it gives me more confidence about Disclosure Day. The direction is straightforward and lets the script do most of the work, even if the effects budget clearly limits what can be shown on screen. He needs a redemption after  Indiana Jones and the Crystal Skull. Joe Keery , known for Stranger Things and Free Guy , is the main reason I showed up. He proves he can handle a leading role after Stranger Things and carries the film with a relax...
Post a Comment
Read more